Reimagining Royalties: Fair Pay in the Streaming Era

The music industry is amidst a seismic shift from outdated payment practices to a more transparent and equitable model. This transformation is driven by innovative platforms like Revelator and emerging subscription models like Vault, which aim to address longstanding issues surrounding artist compensation in the streaming era.

One of the most critical challenges for artists has been the slow and opaque payment processes traditionally associated with music royalties. Revelator is tackling this issue by utilizing blockchain technology and smart contracts to streamline and expedite payments. By tokenizing music rights and employing programmable finance, Revelator allows artists to receive payments instantaneously. For instance, an artist with a million streams can see between $4,000 to $7,000 deposited directly into their digital wallet the following day—a significant leap towards fairer compensation.

Photo of technology interface

Beyond facilitating faster payments, Revelator ensures music is distributed across all major streaming platforms, including emerging NFT marketplaces and Web3 platforms. Additionally, Revelator’s system automates the distribution of earnings among all rights holders, simplifying the complex business side of the music industry.

The UK government is also making strides in supporting fair remuneration for music creators. Following recommendations from the Culture, Media & Sport (CMS) Committee, a new working group has been established to address fair pay issues in the streaming era. This group, which includes representatives from the music sector, is focused on developing actions to ensure fair compensation for current and future music creators.

Despite these positive developments, there are concerns about the potential impact on investment. Sophie Jones, Interim CEO of the BPI, has cautioned that the current environment might disincentivize investment, particularly as labels strive to grow exports and protect artists' rights in the AI era. Nevertheless, significant transparency and royalty payment improvements suggest a promising path forward.

Amidst these changes, debates about streaming royalties continue. Critics argue that flat-rate streaming services are inherently unfair. A subscription model costing $10 per month for unlimited access to music may either overcharge light users or underpay artists who are frequently streamed. The static revenue generated from such models is insufficient to fairly compensate artists, regardless of how the revenue is split between services and creators.

A more equitable approach might involve a tiered payment system. For interactive services like Spotify, where users can search for and play specific tracks, a new royalty structure could be implemented. This could include a base subscription fee plus additional charges based on usage. For instance, a flat streaming royalty rate, akin to the mechanical royalty rate of $0.091 per song per unit, could be established. Algorithmically generated plays could incur a smaller non-interactive royalty fee, while specifically requested tracks could incur a higher, one-time royalty fee.

This model could mean higher costs for consumers who frequently request specific tracks, but it would potentially provide a fairer distribution of revenue to artists. For example, a $10 subscription fee could be supplemented by an additional $3.50 in royalties for non-interactive usage, with an increased fee for interactive usage.

In response to the current royalty model's inadequacies, artist James Blake has launched Vault, a subscription-based platform designed to connect artists directly with fans while addressing compensation concerns. Vault allows users to access unreleased tracks from their favourite musicians for a monthly fee, to provide artists with a more direct revenue stream. Blake’s vision for Vault is to empower musicians to earn fair compensation and reinvest in their creative processes.

However, Vault has faced scepticism regarding its long-term viability and its potential impact on consumers. Critics argue that subscription models like Vault may lead to higher costs for consumers and primarily benefit established artists with large followings. Despite these concerns, Blake's initiative highlights the need for alternative revenue models that prioritize fair compensation for creators.

Man listening to music

As the music industry evolves, the focus on fair pay and transparency is becoming increasingly critical. Platforms like Revelator and new initiatives like Vault are pioneering changes that promise to reshape the landscape of artist compensation. While challenges remain, these innovations offer a glimpse into a future where artists are more fairly rewarded for their work. Balancing the needs of consumers with fair compensation for creators will be key to ensuring a sustainable and vibrant music industry for years to come.